The Greens Against Green

by Dr.Harald Wiesendanger– Klartext

A sunflower in their logo, “nature” in their name, and anthroposophists at their founding: Naturopathy could hardly find a more obvious advocate than the Greens. Instead, they cheerfully turned their backs on it. How a party gives away its very own cause—and, along with it, a potential voter base of 18 million supporters of gentle healing methods.

On the evening of November 28, 2025, a pharmacist from Berlin-Tempelhof takes the podium at the Green Party convention in Hanover. Just a few sentences, and then the hall erupts in cheers. The applause isn’t for a wind turbine, a speed limit, or a climate allowance.

They’re applauding a farewell. Usually, the Greens celebrate only the shutdown of a nuclear power plant with such exuberance.

By a large majority, the delegates decide that health insurance companies should no longer cover homeopathic treatments; they sweep their own federal executive committee’s compromise off the table. Paula Piechotta, a physician and member of the Bundestag, has been familiar with the debate since 2019 and declares it settled: “And today we can put an end to it.” (1)

Of all parties, is it the party of organic farmers, tree conservationists, and anti-nuclear activists that is turning its back on alternative medicine? Who, if not the Greens, would be the natural ally of medicinal plants, therapeutic fasting, and Kneipp hydrotherapy—of whole foods, plenty of exercise, and sufficient sleep—indeed, of everything that strengthens the body’s self-healing powers, prevents illness, and maintains health? (2) The Greens will carry every toad across the street. But they mow down the medicinal herbs growing by the wayside.

Gone are the homeopathic pellets—and so is their credibility

The break didn’t happen overnight. In 2019, the party leadership referred the dispute to a special commission, which it declared a failure in January 2020 (3). Since the adoption of the party platform in the fall of 2020, healthcare has been supposed to be guided by the latest scientific evidence (4)—a phrase as misleading as a weed killer labeled “organic”: harmless on the label, thorough in the garden. “Science” is a field whose supposedly best evidence comes from “controlled” studies, with exorbitant costs that, as a rule, only the pharmaceutical industry can shoulder—and which researches treatments using methods that are, at best, only halfway effective when it comes to pills and injections. (5) These days, evidence is whatever someone can afford.

The Hanover resolution even acknowledges that “ample evidence” exists for herbal remedies (6). Anyone who writes something like that would surely have to demand that they be reimbursed again, wouldn’t they? Not a chance. Since 2004, health insurance plans have no longer covered over-the-counter herbal medicines for adults—a decision made under the Red-Green coalition, with the blessing of the Union (7). Yet the Red-Green coalition agreement had promised to promote alternative healing methods (8). Green electricity receives subsidies, while alternative medicine is excluded from health insurance coverage.

The competition took care of the rest. Within the coalition government, Karl Lauterbach’s push to end reimbursement for homeopathic remedies at the expense of the solidarity-based health system was blocked by the Greens (9). As long as they were part of the governing coalition, the Greens protected homeopathic remedies; but as soon as they found themselves in the opposition, they wanted to get rid of them. A CDU minister carried out the party convention’s wish: Nina Warken’s cost-cutting bill, passed by the Bundestag on July 10, 2026, removes homeopathy from health insurance coverage, even as a voluntary benefit under the insurance statutes (10). The Greens lambasted the package as an imposition on insured individuals (11).

Rarely has a party complained so loudly about the fulfillment of its own wish.

The Forgotten Manners

Have you already forgotten the roots from which the party grew? Among the founders in 1980, anti-authoritarian anthroposophists mediated between the divided camps of environmentalists, conservatives, and leftists; Joseph Beuys, the man with the felt hat, was close to the Achberg Circle, a network of anthroposophically influenced reformers (12).

Since then, there have been repeated advocates of a health policy rooted in nature and open to alternatives to conventional medicine—but they remained isolated voices on the fringes, without any significant influence. Among them is Barbara Steffens, North Rhine-Westphalia’s first Green health minister: She considers “the saying ‘Whoever heals is right’ to be essentially correct.” She openly advocated for homeopathy (13). Prominent party figures such as former Green Party chairman Hans-Christian Ströbele and physician and Member of the Bundestag Johannes Wagner admitted that they had received homeopathic treatment. In 2019, Baden-Württemberg’s Green Minister of Social Affairs, Manne Lucha, warned that anyone who questioned homeopathy was tampering with the party’s “programmatic DNA” (16). In Hanover, Ulrich Geyer from Heidenheim, with motions calling for therapeutic diversity (15), and Yatin Shah (1), a physician practicing integrative medicine, fought for the party’s traditional stance. Their efforts were in vain. Even the treasurer argued in vain that patients should be allowed to make decisions about their own bodies (1).

Alienated: 18 million fans of natural medicine

According to Allensbach, about 18 million Germans place great value on natural remedies and gentle medications (14). Those who turn to homeopathic remedies are more likely than average to have a higher level of education; most users live in Baden-Württemberg and Bavaria (17). Sociologically speaking, it’s a picture-perfect “green” environment. Who is looking out for this huge bloc of voters? “A broad range of therapeutic options, including naturopathy and complementary medicine, is very important to the people of this state,” said Manne Lucha in 2018—not some backbencher, but the Minister of Social Affairs, Health, and Integration for Baden-Württemberg from 2016 to 2026.

On Abgeordnetenwatch, an AfD candidate explicitly told a citizen that he supports freedom of choice regarding homeopathy, naturopathy, and anthroposophy (18). The Greens are leaving the issue by the wayside like a lost wallet. Others have already picked it up.

Green is the color of hope, as the saying goes. For the Greens, it’s now just the party color.

This Belongs in a Green Health Program

How could the Greens return to a green approach to health? First and foremost, they would have to learn to distinguish: Skepticism toward homeopathic pellets is no reason to reject naturopathy as a whole.

Then they would need a program that truly deserves the label “green.” Green medicine would keep people healthy rather than merely fixing them. It would help them help themselves and give doctors time to listen. And it would recognize that sometimes the best treatment is no treatment at all. Where compresses, tea, or exercise have been shown to be sufficient, there is no need for pills or a scalpel—depending on the illness, of course. The specific illness is the decisive factor. Therapeutic fasting, nutritional medicine, exercise therapy, yoga, meditation, and Kneipp treatments could be expanded as “prevention on prescription,” including forest therapy and hospital gardens. Green health policy would take seriously what was already being said years ago: “We must refocus more on the causes of illness, and symptom relief should be seen as part of an overall process. “If, instead of individual medical services, we make the person’s overall condition the measure of successful therapy, medicine can become more efficient and yield better results,” North Rhine-Westphalia Health Minister Barbara Steffens once emphasized. All too many of her party colleagues apparently turned a deaf ear to this.

Germany’s best-known researcher in naturopathy, Andreas Michalsen, holds an endowed chair at the Charité (19)—a green government would fund such chairs with taxpayer money and launch a research program for integrative medicine so that evidence is generated rather than merely demanded. After all, who pays for studies on nettle tea and calf compresses, singing bowls, and spiritual healing? No corporation—there’s no patent on that.

Herbal remedies and many other complementary healing methods with proven benefits belong in the health insurance reimbursement system. Schools, company cafeterias, and hospital kitchens could switch to fresh, regional organic food. At clinics and health centers, integrative outpatient clinics could demonstrate how conventional medicine and naturopathy work hand in hand. Since 2007, the therapy camps run by the Auswege Foundation have demonstrated how straightforward, effective, and cost-efficient such collaboration can be—in a way that fulfills and enriches everyone involved.

During the COVID years, wouldn’t a party that didn’t just use “green” as window dressing have pushed to publicly promote everything that strengthens the body’s own defenses, instead of sitting idly by waiting for Big Pharma to deliver vaccines? Wouldn’t it have had to rein in its strange, pitiful-looking hygiene crusader, Janosch Dahmen, when he of all people—a doctor and the parliamentary group’s health policy spokesperson—pretended that, in times of a pandemic, people no longer had an immune system and were “defenseless” against a virus that was probably no more “raging” than a moderate flu outbreak (20) without a shot? Would she have let him spread the unconfirmed rumor on behalf of the party that “only the vaccine” offers “sufficient protection”?

A lesson from the old master

In June 2026, a prominent Green Party member called in an open letter for homeopathy to remain a benefit covered by health insurance, in accordance with “the preservation of the pluralism of methods enshrined in SGB V and the requirement to take therapeutic diversity into account”: Winfried Kretschmann (21), who served as Green Party Minister-President for 15 years (22). When he signed the letter, he had already left office. Lukas Beckmann, co-founder of the party, also signed it.

The sunflower in the logo is already there. Now all that’s missing is the “healthcare revolution” beneath it.

As for the risks and side effects of Green health policy, dear Green Party member, ask your party elders or your core voters.

(Harald Wiesendanger)

Notes

(1) Rebekka Wiese: Parteitag in Hannover: Grüne verabschieden sich von der Homöopathie, Stuttgarter Zeitung, 29.11.2025

(2) Zu 24 wichtigen Aspekten medizinischer Prävention siehe https://www.stiftung-auswege.de/gesund.html, Rubrik “Wir beugen vor”.

(3) Grüne pochen auf bessere Arzneimittel-Versorgung, Pharmazeutische Zeitung, 01.07.2020

(4) Grüne distanzieren sich von Homöopathie, Ärzte Zeitung, November 2020

(5)  Näheres, in Form eines Gedankenexperiments, in Harald Wiesendanger: Außer Kontrolle. Warum die Stiftung Auswege “unwissenschaftlich” vorgeht – und dazu steht (2016)

(6) Bündnis 90/Die Grünen: Beschluss „Keine Erstattung homöopathischer Leistungen durch gesetzliche Krankenkassen – für eine evidenzbasierte Gesundheitspolitik!“, 51. Bundesdelegiertenkonferenz Hannover, 28.11.2025

(7) Sorgenkind Selbstmedikation, Ärzte Zeitung; Editorial, Zeitschrift für Phytotherapie 2012; 33: 3

(8) Conny Becker: Schwabe sieht Phytos diskriminiert, Pharmazeutische Zeitung, 19.05.2003

(9) Cornelia Dölger: Auch »Tatort«-Kommissare für Homöopathie-Erstattung, Pharmazeutische Zeitung, 18.06.2026

(10) GKV-Sparpaket: Was der Bundestag beschlossen hat, Apotheken Umschau, 10.07.2026; Hufelandgesellschaft: Regelungsvorhaben GKV-Beitragssatzstabilisierungsgesetz, Lobbyregister des Bundestags, 23.06.2026

(11) Cornelia Dölger: Bundestag beschließt GKV-Spargesetz, Pharmazeutische Zeitung, 10.07.2026

(12) Joseph Beuys und die Grünen, Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung, 07.05.2021

(13) Grüne streiten über Homöopathie, Jungle World, 2019

(14) Die Grünen und die umstrittenen Pillen, taz, 2019

(15) Ulrich Geyer (KV Heidenheim): Antrag V-55 „Therapievielfalt im Gesundheitswesen fördern“, 51. BDK, November 2025

(16) Institut für Demoskopie Allensbach: Bevorzugung schonender Medikamente/Naturheilmittel 2019–2024, via Statista

(17) Annette Immel-Sehr: Homöopathika immer beliebter, Pharmazeutische Zeitung, 22.10.2014

(18) Antwort von Bernd Schattner (AfD), Abgeordnetenwatch

(19) 20. Internationaler Fastenkongress der ÄGHE, Ärztegesellschaft Heilfasten & Ernährung

(20) Siehe KLARTEXT-Beiträge https://www.klartext-online.info/post/zum-haareraufen, https://www.klartext-online.info/post/kapiert-ki-die-pandemie) (https://reitschuster.de/post/gruener-corona-paradoxon-aufarbeitung-nicht-noetig/)  

(21) dpa: Prominente fordern Erhalt von Homöopathie auf Kassenkosten, Schwäbische Zeitung, 19.06.2026

(22) Baden-Württemberg: Knapper Sieg für die Grünen, apotheke adhoc, 08.03.2026

See the original post